Collected Advice

Here are some advice and resources I have collected over the last few months along with quotes on what I found particularly useful or interesting.

Writing and Research Advice

  • How to write papers
  • How to ML Paper
  • Writing Related Works Section
  • Jan Van Gemert-Guidelines on Fundamental empirical understanding
  • How to Write Research Papers
  • How to Read a Technical Paper
  • How to find Research Problems
    • Designing a clean comparison does take thought, and carrying it out is often a lot of work
    • Writing a lit review will make you something of an expert, able to talk confidently with other researchers in the area; it will give you an idea of the shortcomings of past research; You can make it available to others via your Web page or an online paper archive.
  • How to write a research paper
  • Good Writing
    • Good writing will permit your readers to concentrate on your ideas, and may help you to give the impression that you know what you are talking (writing) about
    • You must want to produce good writing.
    • You must believe you can produce good writing.
    • Scrutinize each paragraph and revise it until it is a good one.  Topic sentences are particularly helpful and important.  Try to have one main idea for each paragraph.  Paragraphs are good when they say what you want to say, and when all the sentences hang together harmoniously.  When you are reading and rewriting your paragraphs, read them out loud occasionally to get a feel for their rhythm.
    • Scrutinize the glue between your paragraphs.  Make sure that the paragraphs fit together nicely.  Does each paragraph follow from the last and set up the next?
    • Scrutinize each sentence and rewrite it until it is a good one.
    • read your stuff out loud to test it on your ear.

General PhD Advice

  • Resources for Students and Scholars
  • The importance of Stupidity in Scientific Research
    • One of the beautiful things about science is that it allows us to bumble along, getting it wrong time after time, and feel perfectly fine as long as we learn something each time.
  • Resources for Students
  • The Slow Science Manifesto
    • Science needs time to think. Science needs time to read, and time to fail. Science does not always know what it might be at right now. Science develops unsteadi­ly, with jerky moves and un­predict­able leaps forward—at the same time, however, it creeps about on a very slow time scale, for which there must be room and to which justice must be done.
  • Advice for Research Students
  • The three golden rules for successful scientific research
  • Critical Skills for Research
  • Research Agenda
    • Given a big problem, how to decompose it to subproblems and solve them
  • Matt Might’s article index
    • Try those.
    • Effective writing is equally critical to success as an academic.You don’t just need to write more, you need to form a _writing habit.
  • Advice to a Beginning Graduate Student
    • Read what you can.
    • Write in the margins. (You know how useful that can be.)
    • Writing what I read is one of the most enjoyable and profitable ways to learn hard material
    • Without writing, you are reduced to a finite automaton. With writing you have the extraordinary power of a Turing machine.
    • How SHOULD I have been thinking to solve that problem?
    • Make a list for yourself of good ways to pursue a problem. My own favorite is to try small examples.
    • Whatever you do, you got to like doing it…. You got to like it so much that you’re willing to think about it, work on it, long after everyone else has moved on.
    • Be a MENSCH. Use the feedback to improve your paper! Make it better. And send it back.
  • You and Your Research
    •  Most of the time the audience wants a broad general talk and wants much more survey and background than the speaker is willing to give. You should paint a general picture to say why it’s important, and then slowly give a sketch of what was done.
    • become emotionally involved
    • try and change what is difficult to some other situation which is easily done but is still important